Tag: CFTC

  • CFTC Swap Data Reporting in Uncertain Times: 5 Reasons Why It Matters More

    CFTC Swap Data Reporting in Uncertain Times: 5 Reasons Why It Matters More

    Given the backdrop in Washington, clients and industry contacts are asking me if the CFTC remains as focused on reporting and whether firms could consider scaling back their efforts. I understand the logic: a shifting regulatory environment in the US, recent No-Action Reliefs on error correction and notification, and signals of a regulatory pivot towards crypto and fraud.

    Factor in an industry exhausted after years of gruelling rewrites and the case for easing off feels almost compelling. Almost.

    My answer is a categorical nope – and here’s why.

    1. Regulators increasingly use the data for far more than systemic risk monitoring

    The Dodd-Frank Act reporting framework may have originated from the 2008/9 financial crisis with systemic risk the objective, but regulators across the G20 countries are using this data for an expanding range of purposes, including:

    • Market surveillance
    • Position monitoring
    • Market abuse and insider trading detection
    • Policy calibration.

    ASIC’s recent review of the Australian CFD market is a case in point. They used the reported data for consumer protection purposes and the resulting enforcement action secured nearly A$40m in refunds to retail investors. A different use case entirely from the original mandate but made possible by the quality of the underlying data.

    And consider the Archegos collapse. The SEC took significant criticism for what it didn’t see coming. The idea that either the CFTC or SEC would voluntarily walk away from data they’ve spent years working to obtain and improve just doesn’t hold up.

    It’s also worth remembering that the original systemic risk mandate is looking as mission critical as it has been since The Big Short. If anything the environment we’re operating in has made it more relevant:

    • War in the Middle East driving oil prices sky high and damaging the global economy
    • Growing concerns about structural vulnerabilities in the private credit space
    • Questions about whether the current AI boom might be a bubble
    • Significant uncertainty about the risks, opacity and sustainability of cryptocurrency markets (and yes, the irony of arguing for data quality while regulators are being nudged to go easier on crypto is not lost on me)
    • All of the above sitting alongside risks like stretched asset valuations, elevated sovereign debt levels, and a geopolitical risk environment that feels anything but settled.

    2. No-Action Relief letters are not a free pass on data quality

    It would be easy to assume the two recent CFTC No-Action Relief letters (easing the so-called ‘Part 49’ burdens around Error Correction and Error Notification) are a signal that the commission is easing off. It’s actually the opposite.

    Let’s recap:

    • NOAR Letter 25-25 (July 2025) means firms only having to submit a ‘failure to timely correct’ notification where the issue impacts over 5% of the open trades within that asset class.
    • NOAR Letter 25-43 (December 2025) reduces the correction requirements in three main ways:
      • Reduced requirements to correct dead (matured/terminated) trades
      • Corrections focused on the most important fields (LEIs, UTIs, UPIs and Appendix A fields)
      • Only the latest version of any trade needs corrected.

    Collectively, that’s a significant reduction in administrative burden. And credit to ISDA for the advocacy that got the CFTC to this more pragmatic place.

    But the intent is telling. The Commission isn’t saying reporting quality matters less. It’s saying: we’ve cleared away the noise, so now crack on with what really matters. In other words, there are no excuses left. 

    Regardless of where the CFTC sits on enforcement priorities, NFA examinations of swap dealers continue with data accuracy and reporting controls firmly in scope. The same goes for FINRA’s examinations on the SEC side. Reporting quality is not an optional extra.

    And here’s the sting in the tail: those two No-Action Relief letters cut both ways.The NFA will likely expect firms to demonstrate exactly what they’re doing with the correction requirements that remain. Relief from the burdensome stuff is not a pass on the important stuff.

    3. Cross-jurisdiction reporting means issues don’t stay isolated to CFTC

    If your firm is big and important enough to be invited into the Swap Dealers Ballroom, there’s a strong chance you’ve qualified for other equally prestigious obligations. The Security-Based Swap Dealers convention is only two blocks down Fifth Avenue. Toronto and the glamour of the CSA Gala are just a short flight from JFK. And further afield, your international colleagues are getting dressed up for EMIR, ASIC, HKMA and more.

    Even if the CFTC were to signal a reduced focus in data quality – which it won’t – the underlying data, systems and teams that support them tend to have multi-jurisdictional duties. Let your CFTC data grow stale or polluted and there will be a knock-on effect across every other regime you report into.

    As I commented here, the CFTC and SEC recently announced a Memorandum of Understanding that has implications for swap and security-based swap data. The MOU commits the two agencies to sharing access to reported data, combining analytical and monitoring capabilities, and coordinating on examinations and enforcement.

    Given that these two agencies have historically been more territorial than collaborative, that part about sharing analytical capabilities and analysis is game-changing. Likewise, collaboration on monitoring capabilities and examinations is an interesting and sensible development. And none of it points towards a reduced emphasis on data quality, quite the opposite. Factor in the rapid pace of AI tooling and the two commissions will soon be able to pore over your swap data like never before.

    4. The current ‘quiet period’ is the best time to improve your reporting

    The last three or four years of reporting rewrites have been a major slog. Factor in the SEC’s Security-Based Swap Reporting implementation in late 2021 and early 2022, the CFTC ReWrite in 2022, Phase 2 in 2024, and Canada’s CSA Rewrite in 2025 and even firms with purely North American obligations have been living on a near-permanent regulatory deadline treadmill. And regulatory deadlines, as everyone in this industry knows, are not renowned for their flexibility.

    Whilst we wait for the next round of regulatory timelines, it’s entirely understandable to want to take a bit of a breather. But it’s also a missed opportunity.

    With the rewrites bedded in and the next major deadline not imminent, this is precisely the window to tackle the things that always get deprioritised: cleaning up source data, enhancing systems, tightening controls, and investing in the teams that run them. Firms that use this period will be in a fundamentally stronger position than those that don’t.

    Because before long, the CFTC will have fired the starting gun on the remaining phases of the rewrite, or the CSA will have announced timelines for the next iteration of their Derivatives Data Technical Manual. Or both. And we’ll all be back in deadline mode, and those “day two” initiatives will get quietly shelved again. The window is open now – it won’t stay that way.

    5. High quality data is a business asset, not a compliance tax

    Several years of regulatory stress, my once youthful team is now looking like The Battered Bastards of Baseball, and all for what? So that regulators can ensure we’re not the next Bear Stearns?

    Well, not quite. Because it’s not just the regulators who can use this data. You can too. And you should.

    The good news is that within all that regulatory effort your firm has achieved most of the following:

    • Sourced and cleaned up massive amounts of data
    • Associated LEIs to internal client and counterparty codes
    • Collated and normalised data from multiple upstream systems
    • Linked collateral data from a collateral management system with actual trade data
    • Enriched and verified financial product codes and taxonomies with UPI data
    • Implemented multiple data controls that surface anomalies and issues like never before.

    It’s not just the regulators who now have better oversight of your derivatives business. You do too. This data and the infrastructure around it, is an asset. It isn’t siloed like many trading or upstream systems. It spans your entire derivatives business, with potential value extending across risk, finance, operations, legal and commercial functions simultaneously.

    Looking at the reporting data and controls as solely a regulatory burden is not only shortsighted. It’s also a strategic error. There is value within that data if you choose to unlock it.

    So is CFTC Swap Data Reporting still worth the effort?

    The regulatory pressure hasn’t gone away – it’s evolved. The CFTC and SEC have better tools, broader mandates, and now a formal framework for sharing data and analysis with each other. Examination programmes continue. Cross-jurisdictional obligations don’t disappear because Washington feels uncertain. And the quiet period won’t last.

    But beyond the compliance case, the firms that will come out ahead aren’t just the ones that report accurately. They’re the ones that recognise what they’ve built and put it to work.

    The data is there. The infrastructure is there. The only question is whether you choose to treat it as a burden or an asset.

     

     

  • Three long years of G20 regulatory rewrite pain – and what comes next

    Three long years of G20 regulatory rewrite pain – and what comes next

    September’s Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) Rewrite go-live felt like the final milestone in three or four years of regulatory reporting rewrites pain. HKMA’s changes were the last big jigsaw piece in a series of G20 rule revisions that started with the CFTC Rewrite way back in December 2022.

    For firms active across multiple jurisdictions, this hasn’t been “a bit of change”- it’s been a rolling transformation of how OTC derivatives are reported, validated, reconciled and governed.

    In many ways, the last four years of change have mirrored my own journey here at Kaizen. Joining in June 2021 with a remit to lead and expand Kaizen’s North American services we began with the SEC’s Security-Based Swap Reporting (SBSR) implementation. We then pivoted to the first phase of the CFTC’s Rewrite and the changes have been coming thick and fast since then.

    The rewrites in fast forward

    After years of relative stability, the pace since late 2022 has been relentless and has included:

    • December 2022 – CFTC Rewrite
      A complete overhaul of the US derivatives regime: new data standards, more fields, tougher validations and a much sharper view of what “good” reporting looks like.
    • December 2022 – SEC SBSR and Canadian CSA alignment 
      SEC Security-Based Swap Reporting went live in two stages, then was reshaped when the CFTC Rewrite arrived. DTCC was allowed to apply much of the CFTC Rewrite model to Canadian CSA reporting, pulling Canada into roughly the same orbit.
    • January 2024 – CFTC Phase 2
      UPI adoption for everything except commodities, driving more standardisation but more complexity for front-to-back systems and controls.
    • April 2024 – JFSA Rewrite and EU EMIR Refit 
      Japan joined the party with its own rewrite, while the EU’s EMIR REFIT changed fields, formats and lifecycle reporting fundamentally.
    • September 2024- UK EMIR Refit
      A separate but related regime for the UK post-Brexit, with its own implementation and quirks.
    • October 2024 – ASIC and MAS Rewrites
      Australia and Singapore implemented their G20-aligned rewrites, each with local flavour.
    • July 2025 – CSA Rewrite (Round Two) 
      Canada’s second swing, absorbing lessons from earlier reforms and the CFTC-style approach.
    • September 2025 – HKMA Rewrite
      The “grand finale” of this wave, as Hong Kong landed its own version of the global agenda.

    Battered, bruised…and still standing

    Most banks and reporting firms are emerging from this period a bit battered, but undeniably wiser.

    From Kaizen’s vantage point, we’ve seen clients:

    • Rebuild reporting architectures to support ISO standards, UPIs and new lifecycle models
    • Re-map hundreds of fields across multiple regimes under intense time pressure
    • Strengthen control frameworks – especially reconciliations and completeness/accuracy checks – to cope with far more granular data

    It hasn’t always been elegant, but the resilience, dedication and problem-solving across the market has been impressive. If I may be so bold, the industry as a whole should take a moment to give themselves a pat on the shoulder for what has been collectively tackled and accomplished.

    The regulatory change calendar over the last few years was nothing short of ridiculous, but we didn’t flinch, and here we are emerging on the other side.

    Spoiler alert…this isn’t the end

    Tempting as it is to declare victory, the regulatory carousel never really stops. On the G20 reporting side alone, the next wave already includes:

    • January 2026 – UK EMIR validations
      Revised validation rules will tighten expectations on data quality and consistency.
    • April and September 2026 – EMIR Inter-TR Reconciliation uplift 
      The Inter-TR Reconciliation scope is due to increase to around 150 fields in April 2026 for the EU and September 2026 for the UK – a significant jump in matching expectations and breaks management.
    • CFTC: Phase 3 (and maybe 4)
      The CFTC still has UPI adoption for Commodities, 49 proposed fields and a delayed move to ISO 20022 XML waiting in the wings. Whether it lands as one or two further phases, we’re not done.
    • CSA: Derivatives Data Technical Manual v2.0
      Somewhat hilariously, Canada managed to issue a 2.0 version of its Derivatives Data Technical Manual two weeks before the 1.0 version went live on 25 July. Most changes are minor, but it points toward another implementation date once consultation feedback is digested.

    So no, this is not “the end”. It’s more like the end of one particularly brutal season, with the next one already in rehearsal.

    ESMA’s Call for Evidence: Slow and Dangerous

    Alongside all of this, ESMA has launched a Call For Evidence (CFE) on reducing reporting burdens across EMIR, MiFIR and SFTR. The goal is to cut duplication and conflicting standards, something most firms would happily see.

    Trade associations such as ISDA and ICMA have suggested, among other things:

    • Limiting ETDs to MiFIR and OTCs to EMIR
      ETDs would align with market abuse detection under MiFIR, while OTCs sit with systemic risk monitoring under EMIR – which is where they arguably always belonged.

    • Single-sided reporting with a clear hierarchy
      EMIR is still an outlier with dual-sided reporting and mandatory reconciliation of both sides. A move to single-sided reporting and a clear responsibility hierarchy would remove a lot of operational friction.

    Ordinarily, you’d expect ESMA’s CFE to take years to turn into anything concrete. But with US priorities and timelines uncertain – including when the CFTC will tackle its remaining Rewrite elements – ESMA’s slow-and-steady approach may yet deliver the next major structural shift in G20 reporting.

    So where are we now?

    • The first wave of rewrites – CFTC, EMIR, JFSA, ASIC, MAS, CSA, HKMA – is largely through initial implementation
    • A second wave is forming around enhanced validations, expanded reconciliations and “day 2” fixes
    • And in the background, structural debates – like ESMA’s CFE – could reshape the landscape again, hopefully with simplification in mind.

    The bulk of the reporting rewrites have been delivered. But the regulators will continue to assess the data they are receiving and look at what their counterparts have done. Along with the future changes we currently know about, it’s a safe bet that we can expect some more changes to be announced going forward. The carousel continues to spin.

  • Alan McIntyre speaks to Risk.net on the proposed updates to CFTC trade reporting

    Alan McIntyre speaks to Risk.net on the proposed updates to CFTC trade reporting

    The introduction of 49 extra trade reporting fields to a proposed update by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission is being questioned by specialists. Kaizen’s North America Reporting Director spoke to Risk.net on the matter.

    “The update comes alongside an extension of the Unique Product Identifier (UPI) to include commodities, which was expected at some point.

    “It’s telling that so many changes are being made at this stage after all the years the CFTC has spent on the original rewrite.”

     

    Read the full article here.  (You must be a subscriber to view the article in full).

  • CFTC fines and selling the reporting dream

    CFTC fines and selling the reporting dream

    Anyone that’s worked with me or read more than a couple of my ramblings will know that I don’t do sales.

    I’m not being boastful or even modest. It’s just not my forte so I tend to give anything ‘salesy’ a wide berth. I mean no disrespect to the world of selling or the talented people that work in sales. I’m just so bad at it and so far out of my comfort zone that I’d probably give the product away for free rather than get into discussing the dreaded commercials.

    Breaking my rule

    The third quarter of 2021 or more specifically the last four days of September saw a flurry of enforcement actions and fines from the CFTC, that after some careful consideration are leading to me breaking my nothing-salesy rule. Not because I’ve had a change of heart or want to move in a different direction. But the themes within the CFTC enforcement actions are so closely aligned to what we do here at Kaizen Reporting it’s almost impossible to not go there.

    So kindly bear with me whilst I set out the stall.

    Taking back controls

    I always advise clients of the importance of devoting a significant effort to building controls into their reporting systems as well as layering additional controls onto the reporting systems and the reporting data generated. Over the last few years I’ve seen an interesting trend where many firms are moving those controls further up the stack towards the trading systems rather than downstream in the data lake or reporting hub. The ethos being that it’s better to flag the errors at source rather than further downstream where the remediation workflow can be more elaborate, involve multiple systems and take longer.

    I stand by this advice and maintain that it’s not only best practice but it’s absolutely crucial to help detect and prevent errors within your reporting.

    Marking your own homework

    However there is a key limitation which means that these controls, no matter how well designed and implemented are not enough. Simply put, at some stage you inevitably end up marking your own homework. Whether the controls were developed at the same time the reporting system being built or were added later, the vast majority of the time it was the same teams, relying on the same documentation and same interpretations that ended up owning both the reporting and the controls.

    [First salesy spoiler alert]. Independent controls and that unbiased second opinion are key to detecting the issues that your controls and vigilance missed.

    I could labour the point but there’s no need as it’s really that simple.

    [Second salesy spoiler alert]. At Kaizen we offer the best in class data Accuracy Testing (checking the integrity of the reported data), Reconciliations (testing the completeness and accuracy of the reported data versus your source systems) and Reference Data Testing (testing the accuracy of the reference data that your reporting systems utilise to do the reporting). We offer these because it’s our experience of working with many, many clients over many different regulatory regimes that this is what is needed to fully assess the quality of the reporting data.

    We’ve seen it many times over the years in various regulations where an upstream reference data change causes an unforeseen reporting issue downstream. Your own controls might catch such instances, but they also might not. A static data change results in a different value flowing downstream to the reporting system. The value goes out the door and is reported because it’s a valid value, but it’s the wrong valid value.

    CFTC enforcement actions

    Looking at the themes in the recent CFTC enforcement actions will hopefully shine a light on why I’m breaking my embargo.

    • Failure to report LEIs or report the correct LEIs

    Accuracy Testing, Reference Data Testing and Reconciliations.

    • Failure to report swap valuation data or accurate valuations to an SDR

    Accuracy Testing and Reconciliations.

    • Reporting inaccurate swap data to an SDR.

    Accuracy Testing, Reference Data Testing and Reconciliations.

     

    As a firm that spends its entire energies and focus on the world of trade and transaction reporting we know more than most just how challenging these ever changing regulations can be. [Third and final salesy spoiler alert]. That’s why Kaizen Reporting was founded – to help firms with exactly these challenges. 

    The recent CFTC enforcement actions prove that the US regulator is paying close attention and expects the swap data to be reported accurately. With better and more prescriptive data standards coming in the form of the CFTC ReWrite we can only expect their tolerance of reporting issues to decline even further. The CFTC have spent years and a lot of effort on the ReWrite and they are going to expect high quality data reported from the start.

    • For a conversation with Alan or one of our regulatory specialists about the above topics, please contact us.
  • REGISTER: CFTC & SEC Trade Reporting Changes – The Road Ahead

    REGISTER: CFTC & SEC Trade Reporting Changes – The Road Ahead

    Join Kaizen’s Senior Regulatory Reporting Specialist Alan McIntyre and IHS Markit’s Igor Kaplun and Gavin Marcus for a webinar on CFTC & SEC Trade Reporting Changes – The Road Ahead.

     

    When: Thursday 21 October 2021
    Time: 9am EDT/ 2pm BST

     

    The webinar, hosted by IHS Markit, will focus on:

    • Regulatory reporting change is not going away. There will most likely be a revision to the CFTC/SEC rules to incorporate UPI/ISO which will likely coincide with similar changes adopted across regs such as ASIC, MAS, CSA and EMIR
    • UPI and ISO are critical to the harmonization and oversight efforts
    • Key changes to the technical specifications
    • How to improve your reporting whilst tackling the enforced regulatory changes.
     

     

  • Tales from the crypt – the great cryptocurrency derivatives EMIR reportability debate

    Tales from the crypt – the great cryptocurrency derivatives EMIR reportability debate

    Cryptocurrencies are often seen as a great way to get rich quick, or poor quicker. To be honest, if I wanted to lose a shed load of money, I’d much rather nip down the bookies and put it all on Tripod Lad to win the 3:30 at Kempton Park. Whilst it might fall at the first fence, at least I would have some idea about the mechanics preventing it reaching the winning post. However, my approach to losing money is looking increasingly old school. It appears that there’s nobody left on the planet who doesn’t know somebody holding a fraction of a bitcoin in the hope that it will miraculously increase in value enough to put their grandkids through university.

    So, how worrying is the rise of the derivatives on cryptocurrencies? Well, we’ve certainly seen extreme volatility in this asset class, commonly attributed to investor behaviours of herding and regret-aversion. Does this create systemic risk? Well, it’s tempting to believe this asset class isn’t mature enough yet to represent a risk to the entire financial system. However, the launch of exchange traded derivatives on cryptocurrencies has led to involvement of increasing numbers of systemically important financial institutions in this asset class. The CFTC Chairman J. Christopher Giancarlo has warned whilst cryptocurrency derivatives are a relatively small market in terms of systemic risk, it is one that the CFTC needs to watch carefully.

    So, we hope this is a development the EEA regulators are also watching carefully. Surely this is one of the good things about EMIR trade reporting – ESMA and other EEA regulators will have had 6 years of analysing cryptocurrency derivatives to assess whether they could have the potential to grow and become a new threat to financial stability. Or have they? Possibly not, as there is a great deal of confusion in the industry as to whether cryptocurrency derivative instruments are actually reportable at all under EMIR. Whilst some firms have decided to trade report them to trade repositories, others have not. The confusion stems from the definition of reportable derivatives. EMIR takes this definition from MiFID and the FCA has explained that whilst cryptocurrency derivatives are “capable” of being financial instruments under MiFID II, it does not consider cryptocurrencies to be currencies or commodities under MiFID II. This is unfortunate as it leaves firms with the added dilemma that if these derivatives are EMIR trade reportable, exactly how should they be reported. Those firms that have chosen to report have taken the decision to report as commodity derivatives; mainly because the ESMA validation for currency derivatives requires an official ISO currency code and cryptocurrencies do not have one.  However, it is debatable whether reporting cryptocurrencies as commodities will deliver much value to the regulators as they will not be recognisable as cryptocurrencies from the report. Maybe the perfect opportunity to address this issue would have been through the fundamental changes to the reporting technical standards implemented in October 2017.

    The reporting of cryptocurrency derivatives may be one of the “known unknowns” in EMIR reporting. However, there are many known reporting errors in EMIR trade reporting that make it through the ESMA validation scheme. Just because a trade repository has accepted a report doesn’t mean it is error free. Some firms consider EMIR trade reporting to be a “fire and forget” reporting regime apparently forgetting the obligation for “complete and accurate” reporting so long as “T+1” is achieved. However, ESMA’s 2017 Annual Report and 2018 Work Programme makes it abundantly clear that the quality of data reported to TRs is not good enough and needs to be improved.

    How good is your EMIR trade reporting? Our ReportShield™ quality assurance service delivers an independent and comprehensive analysis of the accuracy and completeness of your EMIR trade reports. For a consultation with one of our experts, please contact us.

  • CFTC hints it will follow in ESMA’s footsteps

    CFTC hints it will follow in ESMA’s footsteps

    In the world of derivatives reporting the Dodd-Frank Act (DFA) may be the older cousin of EMIR but if we think about which regime is more mature, EMIR takes the cake. Since the reporting go-live in 2014, EMIR has grown through several different amendments to arrive at where we stand today. Its strict validation requirements aim to provide the data quality that is necessary to measure systemic risk. The CFTC on the other side of the Atlantic has remained relatively quiet since reporting go-live at the end of 2012. That is, until now…

    More complete and accurate data

    The CFTC has published a White Paper which gives a view of which direction the US regulation is heading towards. No awards for guessing that they want ‘more complete, more accurate, and higher quality data’. How can this be achieved? The CFTC is proposing to elaborate on requirements of part 49 to ensure that counterparties and repositories are continuously assessing the integrity of their data and insisting that any inaccurate or missing data is corrected. This can only be achieved if the requirements are clear. In the paper, CFTC admits that part 45 data fields are not well defined and this has led to inconsistent reports which cannot be relied upon for any meaningful analysis.

    The proposal is to take on board the CPMI-IOSCO harmonisation of data elements that were published in April. Amongst others, the report details that LEIs should be mandated to identify counterparties and MICs should be used to identify trading platforms. Sounds quite familiar, doesn’t it? As well as this there is an indication that collateral margin fields will be put in scope for reporting as is the case in EMIR and ASIC jurisdictions.

    Relax of timeliness requirements 

    Further harmonisation is suggested by the timeliness requirements being relaxed to a T+1 model. The philosophy is that if Rome wasn’t built in a day, it won’t collapse in a day either. If firms take the time to agree and confirm the terms of an OTC contract before reporting it, then the data received will be of a higher quality.

    Swaps Regulation Version 2.0 won’t be a complete copy and paste of EMIR though. There is no suggestion that the regime will move to dual-sided reporting and the real-time requirements of part 43, although maybe changing as well in terms of notional capsizes, will remain a unique aspect of Dodd-Frank reporting.

    No exact details or timescales are available yet however we’re pleased to remind our clients that our ReportShield™ accuracy testing service already checks the correctness of these fields under Dodd-Frank, so you can be reassured that you’re already one step ahead of the regulator. Alternatively, if you’d like some assurance that your DFA reporting is accurate, timely and complete, please don’t hesitate to contact us.