Tag: Market Abuse Regulation

  • Kaizen launches groundbreaking MAR360 Solution for Market Abuse detection and prevention

    Kaizen launches groundbreaking MAR360 Solution for Market Abuse detection and prevention

    Unique three pillar approach encompasses revolutionary online market abuse risk assessment tool, trade and communications surveillance technology, and expert-led market abuse training programme

    London, 23 September 2025 – Kaizen, a leading provider of regulatory compliance solutions for global financial institutions, today announced the launch of its revolutionary MAR360 solution – a comprehensive, new suite of products that transforms how financial institutions approach market abuse detection and prevention.

    Kaizen’s MAR360 solution combines cutting-edge technology with regulatory expertise to provide a comprehensive compliance offering covering i) market abuse risk assessment, ii) trade and communications surveillance technology and iii) an expert-led market abuse training programme.

    Transforming how firms manage market abuse

    Designed by former regulators, senior compliance professionals and technology experts, Kaizen’s solution includes a sophisticated online risk assessment tool which analyses firms’ market abuse risks and controls across more than 27 distinct risk areas. These areas have been meticulously crafted to uncover hidden risks that even experienced compliance professionals might miss and are based on regulatory enforcement actions and industry best practices, then enhanced by AI to ensure no vulnerability goes unnoticed.

    Kaizen’s MAR360 solution comprises our proprietary trade and communications surveillance platform as well as an advanced market abuse training programme. The training programme includes ongoing support from subject matter experts and former regulators to help firms remediate issues and gaps in their market abuse risk framework giving clients the assurance they need to meet their regulatory obligations.

    Simon Appleton, Market Abuse & Surveillance Director at Kaizen commented: “Our MAR360 solution moves beyond standard surveillance systems to the proactive management of market abuse risk, supporting the Financial Conduct Authority’s five year strategy to fight financial crime. As global regulators continue to focus on market abuse, firms need to integrate their solutions and controls to demonstrate to regulators how they are taking steps to detect and prevent market abuse incidents happening in the first place.”

    (ends)

    For more information, please contact communications@kaizenreporting.com or visit our website.

  • Kaizen returns to XLoD Global London – 11 & 12 November

    Kaizen returns to XLoD Global London – 11 & 12 November

    Date: 11 and 12 November | Location: Convene, 133 Houndsditch, London, EC3A 7DB | Stand no: 28

    Kaizen is returning to XLoD Global, taking place in London on 11 & 12 November.  Over two days financial institutions and regulators will come together to discuss the future of non-financial risk and control.

    You’ll find the Kaizen team at stand 28 so please stop by to find out how we can help solve your compliance challenges.  We will have representatives from our Surveillance and Market Abuse, Single Rulebook and ReportShield Assurance teams available. 

    We have a limited amount of heavily discounted tickets to give away.  If you’d like to be our guest, please contact us using the button below.

    Contact us

     

  • The FCA’s Approach to Financial Crime: Market Integrity is Non-Negotiable

    The FCA’s Approach to Financial Crime: Market Integrity is Non-Negotiable

    In an important powerful address at the Market Abuse and Market Manipulation Summit on April 28, 2025, Therese Chambers, joint executive director of enforcement and market oversight at the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), laid out the regulator’s comprehensive strategy to maintain market integrity and combat financial crime, including market abuse, through what she terms the “three Ps” approach – being predictable, proportionate, and purposeful.

    Crackdown on Organised Crime: No Mercy for Market Abusers

    Financial crime is at the forefront of the FCA’s agenda and strategy. In her speech in April, Chambers identified Organised Crime Groups (OCGs) as “the most serious threat to our markets,” revealing they account for approximately 25% of all Suspicious Transaction & Order Reports (STORs). The scale of the problem threatening market integrity is staggering – the FCA has identified over half a billion pounds in OCG profits from suspicious trading since 2022 alone.

    As a result, the regulator is taking aggressive action to disrupt these criminal operations, including executing arrests and coordinating with multiple agencies on financial crime both domestically and internationally. This zero-tolerance approach extends beyond OCGs to all forms of market abuse and market manipulation.

    Where firms persistently fail in their responsibilities, the FCA won’t hesitate to intervene with decisive action. A recent example is the restrictions imposed on an investment firm, preventing it from onboarding any new customers to its Contracts for Difference (CFD) business without FCA permission due to inadequate systems and controls for identifying and reporting market abuse.

    Raising the Bar: Sophisticated Threats Demand Sophisticated Controls

    As market abuse techniques evolve in complexity, the FCA is raising expectations for firms’ detection and prevention capabilities. Chambers acknowledged that “those who seek to abuse our markets are becoming more sophisticated. But so are our detection and enforcement capabilities.”

    Firms are expected to implement increasingly advanced surveillance systems that can keep pace with emerging threats. The FCA was explicit that adequate systems and controls to identify and report market abuse are “not just a nice-to-have – it’s a fundamental responsibility.”

    MiFID transaction reports remain vital to the FCA’s work in identifying and acting against market abuse, providing “a rich and unique view of our markets.” This is particularly important during periods of volatility – Chambers noted that on April 7 alone, 76 million transaction reports were received across asset classes, more than double the daily average of 30 million.

    Culture Is Key: Building Market Integrity From Within

    A strong anti-market abuse culture within firms forms the bedrock of the FCA’s strategy. The regulator sees firms as “the first line of defence against market abuse,” and recognises that “most firms work very hard to get it right.”

    Chambers emphasised that firms should not hesitate to offboard entire corporate relationships if they don’t fit their risk profile. “In fact, this is often the right response when risks are identified,” she stated. This highlights the expectation that maintaining market integrity should be prioritised over commercial interests when necessary.

    The value of data combined with collaboration is evident in the FCA’s reliance on Suspicious Transaction & Order Reports (STORs). These reports are described as “invaluable” to the FCA’s work, with over 70% of current market abuse investigations originating from a STOR. Last year alone, the FCA received 4,528 STORs, showing an increasing trend over previous years.

    Market Integrity: The Foundation of Economic Growth

    One of the most compelling aspects of Chambers’ speech was the direct connection drawn between market integrity and economic prosperity. She emphasised that “cleaner markets instil confidence, which encourages investment into our markets, which encourages growth and innovation. It’s a virtuous cycle.”

    The FCA’s 5-year strategy to 2030 includes a dedicated pillar to fighting financial crime, alongside supporting sustained economic growth. Chambers was emphatic that “our work on market abuse is a critical part of all areas of that strategy” and that “market cleanliness and economic growth go hand in hand.”

    Innovation Meets Integrity: The PISCES Initiative

    In a significant move to balance regulation with growth, the FCA has announced plans for a ‘Private Intermittent Securities and Capital Exchange System’, or PISCES – a new type of stock market for private companies that will allow firms to trade shares on a periodic basis, outside the Market Abuse Regulation (MAR) regime.

    This innovative approach is described as a ‘private plus’ mechanism where “transaction reporting will not apply” and “companies will retain more control over aspects of their trading events, such as timing, frequency and participation.” While this represents a lighter regulatory touch to support growth, it’s important to note that the UK’s Criminal Market Manipulation regime will still apply to this market. In addition, MAR would also apply if PISCES shares were admitted to trading to a Multilateral Trading Facility (MTF).

    This initiative demonstrates the FCA’s “calculated increase in our risk appetite to support growth” and willingness to “innovate and take more risks.”

    Recent Enforcement Success: Day Traders Face Consequences

    The FCA’s commitment to enforcement is producing results. As recently highlighted in a LinkedIn post by our Subject Matter Expert for Market Abuse & Surveillance, Simon Appleton, “Wall crossed ‘day traders’ plead guilty to insider dealing,” the regulator is successfully pursuing convictions and confiscating proceeds from illegal activities.

    The case raises important questions about how and why ‘professional day traders’ were routinely provided with non-public, price-sensitive information through ‘wall crossings’ – which are typically used to gauge interest from potential investors rather than traders seeking quick profits.

    Another recent enforcement action demonstrates the critical importance of industry vigilance. Chambers referenced charges against five individuals for insider dealing offences, including a former analyst at an asset management firm, who allegedly used inside information to enable trading that yielded profits of approximately £1.5 million. This case originated from a STOR that prompted further investigation of trading data.

    Looking Ahead: Global Challenges Require Global Solutions

    As suspicious behaviour easily crosses borders, Chambers stressed that “close and cooperative relationships with domestic and international regulators and law enforcement agencies are more important than ever.” The FCA is strengthening its international engagement and strategy to address this reality.

    The regulator is also expanding its focus across asset classes, having “significantly ramped up our effort and coverage across Fixed Income, Currencies & Commodities (FICC) markets.” A recent example includes an investigation into three bond traders regarding alleged manipulation of Italian government bond futures, resulting in bans and fines.

    The message from the FCA is clear: market integrity is non-negotiable. Through their three-pronged approach of being predictable, proportionate, and purposeful, they are determined to create markets that remain hostile to abuse while fostering innovation and growth. As Chambers concluded, “Together, let’s keep building a market that remains hostile to abuse and welcoming to honest participation.” 

  • FCA tells buy-side CEOs that market abuse is a supervisory priority for 2025

    FCA tells buy-side CEOs that market abuse is a supervisory priority for 2025

    Hot on the tail of the Dear CEO letter to wholesale brokers, the latest FCA letter to asset managers and alternatives cites the reduction of financial crime and market abuse within their broader supervisory strategy.

    This Dear CEO letter, from Camille Blackburn the FCA’s Director of Wholesale Buy-Side reveals that the UK regulator will be conducting targeted work in the area of financial crime and market abuse.

    The FCA prompts asset managers that they should be alert to the risk that they could facilitate financial crime and the importance of having robust systems and controls to mitigate this risk. Where the FCA identifies weaknesses in controls they will conduct reviews in the areas such as anti-money laundering controls in private market funds.

    In addition, the FCA repeats that market abuse undermines market confidence and integrity, and that having robust systems and controls are crucial in mitigating this risk.

    The regulator closes with a reminder that they expect firms to:

    • discuss this letter with their Board, Executive Committee, and accountable Senior Managers; and
    • ensure that their market abuse controls enable them to discharge obligations under the Market Abuse Regulation.

    If you would like support with your Market Abuse Risk Assessment framework to help prevent issues like insider trading and market manipulation before they occur, please get in touch. 

     

  • FCA confiscation order demonstrates that insider dealing doesn’t pay

    FCA confiscation order demonstrates that insider dealing doesn’t pay

    Last year the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) secured a successful conviction against Mr Mohammed Zina for six insider dealing offences that took place between 2014 and 2017. Although the profit from the insider dealing totalled just over £140,000, the confiscation order is for nearly £600,000, thus confiscating the entirety of Mr Zina’s assets.

    The order must be paid within three months, or Mr Zina will face an additional five years in prison on top of the original 22 month sentence. The reason the confiscation order is significantly larger than the trading profits is because the court found Mr Zina ultimately benefited across a number of offences, including fraud.

    Although examples of compelling restitution from firms, issuers and individuals were first heard of in Hong Kong, the FCA has increasingly been keen to use these powers.

    In 2017, Tesco agreed to pay redress to 10,000 investors after giving a false and misleading trading update, which was the first redress order under s384 of FSMA 2000. In addition, in 2020 Redcentric Plc agreed to provide compensation to all net purchasers of shares between Nov 2015 and Nov 2016, having misstated accounting balances.

    Long gone are the days when insider dealing was seen as a ‘victimless crime.’ The focus now is not only on securing convictions, but also on ensuring that those benefitting from insider dealing are forced to compensate innocent investors that were on the other side of the orderbook.

    These are very healthy developments in the ongoing drive to uphold market integrity, maintain confidence in the markets and send a clear message that insider trading or fraud in financial markets won’t be tolerated by the UK regulator.

    Additional Resources:

    If you would like support with your Market Abuse Risk Assessment framework to help prevent issues like insider trading before they occur, please get in touch. 

  • FCA highlights linkages between market abuse and money laundering, with another Dear CEO letter

    FCA highlights linkages between market abuse and money laundering, with another Dear CEO letter

    The FCA has written to the chief executives of wholesale brokers setting out their new strategy for supervising the sector. In the letter, the FCA cites the inherent risk that wholesale brokers may be used to execute trades that facilitate financial crime.

    The FCA will be conducting targeted work to assess how firms manage their broker employees and control various inherent risks, including insider trading, market abuse and non-financial misconduct, such as bullying and harassment.

    The letter to wholesale brokers specifically references the link between anti-money laundering controls and market abuse, as well as four Market Watch newsletters, including Market Watch 69 which outlines the benefits of having effective surveillance systems in place and a comprehensive, accurate and up-to-date market abuse risk assessment.

    The UK regulator explains the importance of having a good culture to complement a robust control framework and detective and monitoring controls, including “trade and communication surveillance.”  The expectation is that firms receiving the letter should agree actions and next steps by the end of March 2025.

    Also in relation to financial crime and market abuse, the FCA published a paper last week entitled ‘Assessing and reducing the risk of Money Laundering Through the Markets (MLTM)’, which the FCA expects firms to read in full.

    The MLTM paper, which applies to investment firms more broadly, highlights: the advantages of an integrated approach to market abuse and money laundering surveillance; the benefits of trading surveillance alerts being considered alongside KYC and other information; and that Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) often originate from Trade Surveillance alerts and Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs).

    Additional Resources:

    To learn more about how Kaizen could help your firm with its Market Abuse Risk Assessment framework, please get in touch. 

  • FCA’s Discussion Paper starts to shape the UK’s Market Abuse Regime for Crypto Assets

    FCA’s Discussion Paper starts to shape the UK’s Market Abuse Regime for Crypto Assets

    Following confirmation from the government last month that it will introduce legislation to bring crypto assets into the FCA’s regulatory perimeter, the UK regulator has published a Discussion Paper (DP) that includes market abuse related considerations.

    The roadmap indicates that a Consultation Paper covering Market Abuse, Admissions and Disclosures will be published in Q3 2025 with the FCA’s Crypto regime scheduled to go live in 2026.

    It’s clear from the DP that the FCA will carefully consider the competitiveness of the UK crypto assets market but it’s also apparent that the proposed Market Abuse Regime for Crypto assets (MARC) intends to reduce the incidence of market abuse, lessen information asymmetries and reduce harm to consumers, thus increasing confidence and market growth.

    The MARC framework approach intends to prevent, detect, and disrupt crypto asset market abuse and help prevent regulatory arbitrage by aligning with global standards, including the IOSCO CDA Recommendations covering Market Abuse, Surveillance and Material Non-Public Information.

    New legislation is expected to require the disclosure of inside information in relation to crypto assets traded on a regulated Crypto Asset Trading Platform (CATP) as well as prohibit insider dealing, the unlawful disclosure of inside information and market manipulation.

    Challenges

    The existing market abuse regime cannot simply be transferred to crypto asset markets, given the highly fragmented and cross-border nature of these markets, issuers being less identifiable, the decentralised price formation processes and greater participation from retail consumers making the surveillance process more difficult.

    However, the fact that the FCA acknowledges these key challenges, coupled with the questions being raised in the DP being so considered and broad, appears to be a positive development for the crypto assets sector and the proposed UK MARC regime.

    Comments on the FCA’s DP must be submitted to the regulator by 14 March 2025.

    Additional Resources:

    To learn more about how Kaizen’s surveillance solution could help your firm comply with global market abuse regulation or for assistance with your market abuse risk assessment, please get in touch. 

  • WatersTechnology explains why Kaizen selected as Best Buy-Side Market Surveillance Tool/Platform

    WatersTechnology explains why Kaizen selected as Best Buy-Side Market Surveillance Tool/Platform

    In November, Kaizen won Best Buy-Side Market Surveillance Tool/Platform in the WatersTechnology Buy-Side Technology Awards. In this article, WatersTechnology explains why Kaizen was selected. 

    “Kaizen’s surveillance solution combines sophisticated technology with regulatory expertise to offer buy-side clients a continually evolving surveillance and market abuse platform. In the last 12 months, the firm launched a multi-solution AI voice transcription model as well as a market abuse risk assessment framework and guidance, which sit alongside the platform.”

    Read the full article at waterstechnology.com

  • Kaizen wins Best Buy-side Market Surveillance platform at WatersTechnology – Buy-Side Technology Awards 2024

    Kaizen wins Best Buy-side Market Surveillance platform at WatersTechnology – Buy-Side Technology Awards 2024

    London, 4 November 2024 – Leading regulatory technology firm, Kaizen, has won ‘Best Buy-side Market Surveillance platform’ at this year’s WatersTechnology Buy-Side Technology (BST) Awards for its Surveillance Solutions. This is the fifth WatersTechnology award that Kaizen has won in recent years.

    The WatersTechnology BST awards recognise leading technologies and third-party vendors in their areas of expertise, through an auditable and transparent methodology underpinned by a panel of WatersTechnology’s five most senior and experienced journalists.

    Kaizen’s proprietary surveillance solutions provide trade and communications monitoring on one system to help middle office and compliance teams comply with market abuse regulations and record keeping rules bringing analysts the market intelligence and data they need to operate in an efficient and effective manner.

    Dario Crispini, CEO of Kaizen commented: “We are honoured to have been selected as the ‘Best Buy-side Market Surveillance platform’ at this year’s WatersTechnology BST Awards. It is essential that firms have the right surveillance solutions and monitoring tools in place that allow them to adhere to market abuse and record keeping regulations globally and that they are able to detect all forms of market manipulation.”   

    “This year’s Buy-Side Technology Awards were one of the biggest ever with 223 entries across the 37 individual categories,” said Victor Anderson, global content director of WatersTechnology “Kaizen stood out as the clear winner in the best buy-side market surveillance platform category, thanks to its surveillance solutions, which allow buy-side firms to monitor trade and communications activity in one stream.”

    (ends)

    For more information, please contact James Dunseath, Communications Advisor, on +44 (0) 7557 955795 or media@kaizenreporting.com

  • FCA pushing firms to be more intrusive when trading for ‘obfuscated overseas aggregated accounts’

    FCA pushing firms to be more intrusive when trading for ‘obfuscated overseas aggregated accounts’

    Market Watch 80 highlights the potential risks associated with trading for overseas clients who operate aggregated accounts with unknown ultimate beneficial owners (UBOs). While these accounts offer administrative advantages, they can be used to conceal suspicious trading activity and facilitate market abuse.

    The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has observed an increase in such activity, particularly in leveraged equity products, and particularly in firms overseas where the regulatory approach to market abuse may not be equivalent to that of the FCA. They have identified instances where FCA authorised firms unknowingly executed trades for individual UBOs who had previously had their own trading accounts terminated due to suspected market abuse.

    To mitigate these risks, the FCA recommends firms take extra precautions when onboarding and dealing with ‘obfuscated overseas aggregated accounts’ (OOAAs). This includes modifying risk frameworks, requiring additional information from OOAAs, and applying robust measures to terminate relationships if necessary.

    Whilst the FCA acknowledges it is harder to detect market abuse when the identity of the underlying client is not known, the regulator recommends and encourages firms to be more intrusive with their clients in these situations.

    Simon Appleton commented:

    “Regulated Investment Exchanges and operators of trading venues have historically questioned the market abuse related controls of member firms. Although the commercial nature of the relationship between firms and their clients is different to that between operators and members of trading venues, the suggestion here is that firms need to be more on the front foot with their clients and be more intrusive in a similar manner to the approach taken by exchanges and their members.”

    Given that it is the responsibility of all investment firms in the execution chain to have effective market abuse related systems and controls in place, these steps are a way of protecting the firm from being used to facilitate insider dealing or market manipulation.

    Additional Resources:

    Read Market Watch 80 in full on the FCA’s website..

    To learn more about how Kaizen’s surveillance solution could help your firm comply with global market abuse regulation or for assistance with your market abuse risk assessment, please get in touch. 

  • High stakes mean compliance monitoring of unauthorised communications required

    High stakes mean compliance monitoring of unauthorised communications required

    A US bank received heavily reduced fines from the US SEC and CFTC for proactively admitting unauthorised channels were used for business-related communications which were neither recorded nor monitored.

    According to the CFTC the bank is the only firm to self-report their recordkeeping and supervisory failures.

    It is not enough to have policies and attestations

    What these fines show is that it is not enough for firms to have a list of approved communication channels that are monitored, subject to review and when appropriate archived.

    It was also not enough that the bank required regular attestations from dealers that they were not using personal text messages and social interactions to engage in business-related communications.

    Compliance monitoring, disciplinary action and enforcement are all key

    It was the failure of the bank to ensure that employees complied with their communications policies and procedures. It was also the failure of the bank to maintain those business-related communications and failing to supervise its business effectively.

    Although approaching employees about the usage of personal devices is a sensitive area, the stakes are so high because their unauthorised usage can undermine the effectiveness of the market abuse regime.

    Given the importance of market integrity and confidence in the financial services sector, the proactive compliance monitoring for breaches of the firm’s communication policy and procedures is key.

    Being clear about the firm’s business-related communications policy, as well as informing employees about the firm’s disciplinary and escalation processes is also essential.

    These controls should already be in place for firms that have conducted and acted upon a comprehensive market abuse risk assessment (MARA). The potential for regulatory enforcement action is high for firms with gaps in their controls.

    Additional Resources:

    CFTC Orders Truist Bank to Pay $3 Million Penalty and Remediate Recordkeeping and Supervision Failures Relating to Widespread Use of Unapproved Communications Methods

    Twenty-Six Firms to Pay More Than $390 Million Combined to Settle SEC’s Charges for Widespread Recordkeeping Failures

    • To learn more about how Kaizen’s communications platform could help your firm comply with global market abuse regulation or for assistance with your market abuse risk assessment, please get in touch. 
  • FCA Market Abuse Surveillance TechSprint – What We Learned

    FCA Market Abuse Surveillance TechSprint – What We Learned

    Last month we were excited to take part in the FCA’s Market Abuse Surveillance TechSprint which brought together industry participants to explore AI-powered solutions to help detect forms of market abuse.

    We asked our Head of Operations for Surveillance Charles Dickson, Data Scientist Josian Quintana-Arroyo, and our subject matter expert Simon Appleton about their experiences taking part in the event and what they learned from it.

    First things first, what was your role in the TechSprint?

    Charles: I was the project manager, coordinating within our team and with the FCA. I ensured our project remained true to the TechSprint objectives whilst providing tangible benefits to our clients. This was done by constantly linking our research back to (i) the presentation and knowledge we would be able to share on the demo day at the FCA, and (ii) the enhancements we could roll out to our clients upon project completion.

    Jos:  My role was technical: data science and machine learning. I investigated the data, engineered variables and applied AI methods to detect market abuse.

    Simon: I provided subject matter expertise covering market abuse, surveillance, MiFIR transaction reporting data and order book data.

    What was the problem we were given to explore? Were we successful with our approach?

    Charles:  We chose to explore how to ‘transform market abuse surveillance by incorporating anomaly detection’. This is because we had an existing research project in this area which would allow us to immediately start applying these ideas to the vast datasets which the FCA helpfully gave TechSprint participants access to. In our case, given Kaizen’s rich history and deep knowledge in transaction reporting, it was that dataset we were most interested in.

    Jos: There was success showing our approach was correct although further work is being carried out. This is because detecting market abuse is a complex process that requires a lot of analysis and consensus. There were some false positives. The variables we engineered were relevant and our approach showed results consistent with other datasets which is how we knew we were on the right track.  However, many of the potential anomalies flagged required further investigation. This ‘further investigation’ aspect of product development is a critical part of developing a meaningful algorithm.

    Simon: It was clear that our data scientists, programmers and product development staff benefitted from having access to an extensive and broad dataset covering transaction reports, orders and prices. We also further advanced our understanding and usage of AI in the anomaly detection process.

    What was your biggest learning from taking part in the TechSprint? Do you have any advice for individuals and firms taking part in future events?

    Charles: Thanks to AI, we have a rapidly improving toolset available to us. It is our responsibility to apply these with careful thought and discretion so that the resulting output is explainable and defensible, both for clients and regulators. With the vast options available, it is best to have a targeted approach to return specific answers rather than generating an exponentially growing set of questions. To get these answers implemented with clients, you need to prove additive value to existing rules-based monitoring – reduced false positives with better true positive detection, allowing compliance officers to concentrate more of their time investigating breaches and near-misses.

    Jos: We learned a lot from engineering a model with so much data. We also had the chance to refine our current algorithms as all the fresh data allowed us to shed light on our own work: for example, we reconsidered the importance of two variables that we currently use. Having to explain our findings to an audience also made me think of the problem from a different point of view and I am now testing the same models with a simpler approach which will make them more easily interpretable.

    My advice to others would be to move fast and come up with end-to-end solutions and improve them later, time feels a lot shorter when having to handle so much data. Also to be honest with yourself about the results if they are not as good as expected, there is a lot to learn from what doesn’t work as intended.

    Simon: Although obvious, the importance of having data scientists, programmers, product and market abuse surveillance experts working well together and learning from each other made it exciting and resulted in a positive atmosphere and outcome. Selecting people with the relevant, complementary skills, knowledge and a collaborative approach would be my main suggestion.

    Along with our TechSprint participation, we recently announced we are introducing a new AI powered voice transcription functionality on our communications surveillance platform. What is your advice for firms when assessing AI powered tools?

    Charles: Firms should run AI powered tools in parallel with conventional processes to ensure they are achieving at least the same effectiveness before migrating fully to AI. This would involve a multi-month period with in-depth comparison and human feedback. Categories for assessment would include transparency, defensibility, effectiveness, efficiency, and synergies to other monitoring processes.

    Jos: Some tools are very easy but expensive to implement especially when scaling up. Some more rudimentary approaches are effective albeit more difficult to implement, and they will be worth the saving in costs. Be realistic and well informed about what the latest technology can and cannot do. Some tools can improve performance even if they don’t do the work for you; they could still be valuable.

    Simon: Given that this is a fast-moving environment, keeping your options open, opting for shorter contract periods and selecting a provider that has hedged their bets, rather than opting for a single solution.

  • Insider dealing related STORs back into pole position in Europe

    Insider dealing related STORs back into pole position in Europe

    ESMA’s recent report relating to Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs) provides the market with an overview of their use in different EU countries.

    STORs are an important tool for NCAs to detect, monitor and investigate practices relating to market abuse. MAR requires firms or individuals to report orders and transactions that could constitute insider dealing, market manipulation or attempted insider dealing or market manipulation to the NCA of the trading venue.

    In earlier ESMA reports it was evident that Brexit had a significant impact on the STOR related statistics. This report focusses on STORs received during 2023 and although the conclusion is that the figures are consistent compared with the previous years, there are several interesting observations, including:  

    • the total number of STORs submitted rose by 12% to 6,530, compared to 5,833 in 2022
    • Germany again submitted the most by raising 33% of the total but this was down from 42% last time with German investment firms submitting 3% fewer STORs than in 2022
    • Sweden, a country that prides itself on the quality of its market abuse surveillance, submitted the third highest number of STORs, with 9% of the total and significantly more than many other countries. The number of STORs solely from investment firms in Sweden was up 3% on 2022
    • the ratio of notifications by trading venues (10%) and investment firms (77%)
    • the percentage of STORs by instrument type remained stable with shares accounting for 85%, bonds 7% and derivatives 5%.

    Insider dealing vs market manipulation

    One of the interesting aspects of the report is seeing that more STORs now relate to insider dealing than market manipulation. Although this was always historically the case, the opposite has been true during recent years.

    Insider dealing related STORs accounted for 51% in 2023, up from 45% of the total in 2021 and 44% in 2022. Whereas alleged market manipulation accounted for 47% in 2023, down from 52% of the total for the previous four years.

    Although this annual report from ESMA excludes STORs received by the UK’s FCA, it still highlights some interesting trends. It is too early to say whether the increase in STORs relating to insider dealing is a sign that firms are becoming more sophisticated in their approach towards surveillance, including electronic communications surveillance.

    • For a conversation with Simon about your market surveillance challenges or a demo of our integrated trade and communications surveillance system, please get in touch. 

     

  • Kaizen’s AI powered voice surveillance set to revolutionise communications monitoring

    Kaizen’s AI powered voice surveillance set to revolutionise communications monitoring

    London, 17 July 2024 – Leading regulatory technology firm, Kaizen, is introducing a new artificial intelligence (AI) powered voice transcription functionality on its communications surveillance platform.  

    By using the latest technology Kaizen can bring the same fast search and flexible rule-based monitoring that clients already experience on email and chat messages, to audio communications.

    Kaizen’s Chief Product Officer Rory McLaren, said, “Anecdotal evidence suggests that the type of behaviour organisations need to monitor takes place on the phone more than in written communications where people are more aware they’re being monitored. This new functionality makes it easier for firms to be confident they’re monitoring all forms of communication.”

    Adopting AI in a safe and secure way

    Kaizen has been researching and analysing recent developments in and different models of AI to understand how this technology can revolutionise surveillance and compliance workflows. 

    Rory adds, “We will only use AI where it can add value in a high quality, reliable, cost-effective, safe and secure way. Recent advances in voice transcription have improved the technology dramatically to the point that it is now a viable and valuable addition to surveillance workflows.”

    Choice of voice transcription models 

    Kaizen expects technology in this area to continue to improve, but in such a fast-moving space it is difficult to predict which approaches will be winners in future. Kaizen’s approach is therefore to offer its clients a choice of voice transcription models to use at any given time.

    Kaizen launched its trade and communications surveillance platform in 2023 following its acquisition of Red Deer.

    (ends)

    For more information, please contact James Dunseath, Communications Advisor, on +44 (0) 7557 955795 or media@kaizenreporting.com

  • Kaizen returns to XLoD Global London

    Kaizen returns to XLoD Global London

    Date: 13 and 14 November | Location: Convene Sancroft, St Paul’s, London, EC4M 7DQ | Stand no: 29

    Kaizen are returning to XLoD Global taking place in London on 13 & 14 November.  Over two days the event will explore Innovation & Collaboration: Advancing non-financial risk management across the 3 lines of defence.

    Our Market Abuse, Surveillance & MiFIR Transaction Reporting Director, Simon Appleton will join a panel discussion on Understanding Regulatory Expectations for Communication Surveillance at 10:55 on 13 November.  The panel will discuss the guidelines and standards regulators set for communications surveillance and how they may evolve in the future, the importance of surveillance and material risk assessments and how firms can proactively adapt their communication surveillance to align with the shifting regulatory expectations.

    You’ll also find the Kaizen team at stand number 29 so do stop by for a chat.

    We have a limited amount of heavily discounted tickets to give away, please contact us using the button below.

    Contact us

     

  • Market abuse risks for the buy-side not limited to insider dealing

    Market abuse risks for the buy-side not limited to insider dealing

    At a recent market abuse event it became obvious that the general feeling in the room was that market manipulation risks are not the primary concern for many asset managers. Although insider dealing was seen as the main market abuse risk for buy-side firms, the risk of market manipulation should be treated just as seriously.

    Ability to manipulate prices

    Buy-side firms have historically been seen as users of markets but over the last few years they have increasingly been able to directly impact the price formation process and, with it, the potential to create a false and misleading impression of trading interest.

    A significant percentage of asset managers are now direct market participants on trading venues, mainly multi-lateral trading facilities but some regulated markets too. In addition, with the advent of direct electronic access, asset managers can directly route orders to a wide variety of markets, including via the use of algorithmic trading.

    The ability to manipulate prices can also come through the usage of non-binding Indications of Interest (IOI) messages, misuse of Request for Quote functionality, conditional orders and “off-venue crosses” and so, it becomes clear that the risk of market manipulation exists quite broadly at inherent level. Lastly, the ability to release false and misleading news is there for any market user.

    Motivation

    Where clients and funds sit on large positions (long or short) there can be a heightened focus on whether the positions are showing a paper profit or loss, and this focus can intensify on key dates and at year end.

    Market manipulation at year end

    An interesting market abuse case involved Stefan Chaligné, a fund manager, and Patrick Sejean, a trader, who bought shares minutes before Chaligné’s lviron Fund was to be valued. The value of the fund was artificially inflated and Chaligné’s performance fee boosted by more than £260,000.

    Sejean emailed the following to an unnamed colleague shortly after speaking to Chaligné: “Please buy in the last hour of trading …The goal is to put each stock price as high as possible at the close, so if you want you can buy most of the volume at the close.”

    The purchase of shares on New Year’s Eve resulted in a 2.9% uplift in the value of the £70m fund at year end. The UK’s regulator fined Mr Chaligné (the fund manager) £900,000 plus €362,950 disgorgement of benefit (profits gained from the manipulation). Lastly, the fund manager was deemed not a fit and proper person and was banned from performing any regulated activity.

    Although this case, from 2013, highlights the importance of trade and communications surveillance, importantly, the fund manager could now independently use direct electronic access to transmit orders directly to the market.

    Market abuse risk assessments

    While it’s impossible to eliminate all risks, some market manipulation risks can be reduced through using centralised dealing desks and having a robust market abuse control framework in place.

    Conducting up-to-date and periodic market abuse risk assessments will help a firm identify the risks and ultimately help mitigate them where possible.  It also demonstrates to internal audit and risk management teams, as well as regulators that a firm has the correct risk assessment policies and procedures in place and is doing all it can to reduce the risk of the firm committing or facilitating market abuse.

  • FCA expects robust and increasingly sophisticated market abuse surveillance controls

    FCA expects robust and increasingly sophisticated market abuse surveillance controls

    In Market Watch 79, the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has shared its observations concerning failures of market abuse surveillance at authorised firms, and observations stemming from their peer review of firms’ testing of front-running surveillance.

    Failures of market abuse surveillance were frequently caused by the faulty implementation of surveillance systems, poor change management controls that introduced errors, and missing necessary information feeds, such as trade or order data for certain business flows.

    The impact of these failures meant that certain business flows were not monitored and that alerts were either partially or wholly ineffective due to inadequate testing. The length of time it took firms to identify and fix these failings ranged between a few weeks or less to two years or more. Coincidentally, a firm in the US was recently fined $350 million as a sub-set of trading and order data had not been feeding into their surveillance platforms, as outlined here.

    The FCA observed that one firm had not activated a news feed to facilitate the identification of insider dealing, a failure found only after contact from FCA. Separately, the poor design and setting of a firm’s insider dealing alert parameters, led to potentially suspicious activity going undetected for several years.

    In a separate review, the FCA looked at the frequency and methods used by several large investment firms to test the effectiveness of their client order front running models. Some firms had no formal process covering this, whereas some focused their reviews too heavily on parameter calibration. The FCA cites factors to consider, including the type of financial instrument, the market participants involved, trading methods and trading venues accessed.

    Finally, the FCA helpfully lists the steps firms should take to help prevent surveillance failures, including:

    • Ensuring all relevant trade and order data is accurate and captured
    • Having comprehensive governance arrangements as well as documentation covering testing
    • Appropriate tailoring of alert models and testing by second line and internal audit
    • Having processes to proactively guard against surveillance failures

    It’s clear that the FCA is increasingly stressing the importance of having effective market abuse surveillance by conducting deep dive, thematic and peer reviews and identifying weaknesses in the controls at firms.

    The UK regulator is pushing the boundaries further than before by highlighting that their expectations, and what they see as best practice, are becoming more advanced and sophisticated.

    Given the profound consequences for firms getting this wrong, the FCA is encouraging firms to review the observations in their latest MarketWatch newsletter and consider the adequacy of their arrangements.

    At Kaizen, our proprietary surveillance solutions provide trade and communications monitoring on one system to help middle office and compliance teams comply with market abuse regulations and detect spoofing, layering and other forms of market manipulation.

    • For a free demo of our surveillance solutions, please contact us.
    • Read the MarketWatch newsletter in full on the FCA’s website.
  • Kaizen Selected as FinCrimeTech50 Company

    Kaizen Selected as FinCrimeTech50 Company

    08 May 2024, London – Leading regulatory technology firm, Kaizen today announced that it has been selected for the FinCrimeTech50 listing, an exclusive directory which highlights the leading firms in the world of financial crime and fraud prevention, and organisations who are focused on supporting businesses in developing their financial crime risk management strategies.

    The finalists were selected by a distinguished panel of analysts and industry experts. The judges were given the task of reviewing a list of over 400 nominated enterprises with FinTech Global providing detailed information on each business to help reach a decision.

    Kaizen’s proprietary surveillance solutions provide trade and communications monitoring on one system to help middle office and compliance teams comply with market abuse regulations bringing intelligence analysts the sources they need to operate in an efficient and effective manner.

    Kaizen CEO Dario Crispini, said:

    “We are honoured to have been selected as a FinCrimeTech50 company and to have been recognised for the surveillance solutions we provide to the industry. Having the right analytic tools in place is essential for firms that want to demonstrate that they are considering all relevant market abuse risks and are in compliance with the Market Abuse Regulations (MAR).”

    FinTech Global director Richard Sachar said, “As global financial crime trends continue to rise, compliance teams face growing datasets that outpace traditional tools. Given this pressure, financial institutions are increasingly turning to AI to improve their fraud prevention, biometrics, risk management tools, process automation, and data analytics.

    “The FinCrimeTech50 list will help senior compliance professionals filter through all the solution providers in the market by highlighting the tech leaders in the market who can help financial institutions stay ahead of fraudsters and criminals in 2024 and beyond.”

    (ends)

    • For more information, please contact James Dunseath, Communications Advisor, on +44 (0) 7557 955 795 or media@kaizenreporting.com.

     

  • How Surveillance Platforms can help Prevent Data Leaks

    How Surveillance Platforms can help Prevent Data Leaks

    Data is the lifeblood of the modern world, but its increasing vulnerability to leaks and breaches poses a significant challenge. In the age of digital communication, sensitive information can be just a click away from falling into the wrong hands. Fortunately, communications surveillance tools are emerging as a critical defence against data leaks. In this article, we explore how these tools can be deployed to prevent data leaks and safeguard valuable information.

    The Data Leak Dilemma

    Data leaks can have devastating consequences for organisations, including the exposure of private data and confidential information, financial losses, damage to reputation, legal liabilities, and the erosion of customer trust. Common types of data leaks include:

    • Unauthorised Access: When individuals gain unauthorised access to confidential data, either internally or externally.
    • Insider Threats: Employees or contractors intentionally or unintentionally disclosing sensitive information.
    • Phishing and Social Engineering: Cybercriminals manipulate individuals into revealing confidential data or login credentials.
    • Third-Party Compromise: Data leaks can occur through third-party vendors or service providers with access to an organisation’s systems.

    The Role of Communications Surveillance Tools

    Communications surveillance tools have traditionally been associated with compliance and risk management. However, they are increasingly recognised for their vital role in proactively preventing data leaks. Here’s how they can be deployed for this purpose:

    • Emails: Surveillance tools can scan emails for sensitive data, attachments, or suspicious patterns indicative of data leaks, such as the use of personal email addresses.
    • Chat and Messaging Apps: These tools can monitor internal and external communications for signs of data sharing or compromise.
    • Voice Calls: Surveillance software can analyse voice calls to identify keywords or phrases related to data leaks.
    • Alerts: Surveillance software can send timely alerts when it detects unusual communication patterns, large data transfers, or unauthorized access attempts.
    • Algorithms: the platform can flag irregular behaviour, such as accessing confidential data outside of normal working hours.
    • Behaviour Analysis: Surveillance software can analyse user behaviour to identify potential insider threats or suspicious activities that may lead to data leaks.
    • Data Loss Prevention (DLP) solutions: often integrated with surveillance tools, they can classify and tag sensitive data, ensuring it is not shared inappropriately.

    Challenges and Considerations

    While communications surveillance tools are valuable in preventing data leaks, there are important considerations to bear in mind:

    • Privacy Concerns: Balancing the need for security with employee privacy is crucial. Clear policies and transparency are essential to address these concerns.
    • Data Encryption: Implementing end-to-end encryption can make surveillance more challenging. Organisations need to strike a balance between security and surveillance capabilities.
    • False Positives: Overly aggressive surveillance can lead to false positives, impacting productivity and potentially causing employee morale issues.
    • Compliance: Organisations must ensure that their surveillance practices comply with relevant data protection and privacy regulations.

    Why it’s important

    In a world where data is both an asset and a liability, data security has become a paramount concern for organisations of all sizes. Communications surveillance tools, when implemented thoughtfully and responsibly, play a pivotal role in safeguarding sensitive information and mitigating the risks associated with data leaks. By proactively monitoring communication channels, detecting anomalies, and responding swiftly to potential threats, organisations can fortify their defences and protect their most valuable data assets from falling into the wrong hands.

    Where companies already have these tools in place for workflows like market abuse monitoring, not additionally leveraging them for other use cases could be a missed trick. 

     

    • Please get in touch to see how our communications surveillance platform could help you improve data security and prevent leaks.
  • FCA to help develop market abuse regimes for Crypto Assets and Private Intermittent Securities

    FCA to help develop market abuse regimes for Crypto Assets and Private Intermittent Securities

    The FCA recently published its 2024/25 business plan where it outlined a number of priorities, including that it will continue to deliver on its public commitment to “take assertive action on market abuse”. During the next financial year this commitment will involve the FCA:

    • Increasing their ability to detect and pursue cross-asset class market abuse, including fixed income and commodities;
    • Issuing a discussion paper on transferring MiFID data reporting regimes for transactions (RTS22) and reference data (RTS23) as part of the Smarter Regulatory Framework (SRF) process;
    • Assisting in delivering a proportional market abuse regime for Crypto Assets and the Private Intermittent Securities and Capital Exchange System (PISCES) facility;
    • Extending their data reporting supervision approach to EMIR, SFTR and Orderbook regimes;
    • Publishing the results of their peer review of market abuse systems and controls in providers of Direct Market Access (DMA); and
    • Publishing updated Market Cleanliness Data in Q3 2024

    Market abuse regime for Crypto assets

    It’s too early to tell but it is expected that the market abuse regime would apply to all persons committing market abuse on a crypto asset that is admitted to trading on a UK trading venue, regardless of where the person is based or where the trading takes place. 

    In addition, UK based crypto asset trading venues will be required to have controls to detect and disrupt market abuse and report suspicious activity to the UK regulator.

    Private Intermittent Securities and Capital Exchange System (PISCES) facility

    As anticipated, PISCES will allow privately held companies to open ‘intermittent trading windows’ in which shareholders can sell existing shares through its platform. Buyers in the trial period are likely to be limited to institutional and professional investors, although this could be expanded to include sophisticated and high-net worth investors.

    From the UK Treasury’s Consultation Paper relating to PISCES, the proposed market abuse regime will draw on existing definitions and concepts from MAR where appropriate. The proposed regime will also focus on the greatest market abuse risks in the context of PISCES (to avoid being disproportionate) and the scope will be limited to on-PISCES trading. The three market abuse offences under MAR, which the government intends to apply to PISCES are unlawful disclosure of inside information, market manipulation and insider dealing.

    In relation to the monitoring and enforcement against market abuse on the PISCES facility:

    • market participants, such as the PISCES operator and intermediaries, will need to establish and maintain effective arrangements, systems and procedures to prevent, detect and report suspected market abuse to the FCA
    • the PISCES operator would also be subject to requirements to ensure fair and orderly markets
    • the FCA will be the statutory authority for investigating and taking any enforcement action
    • participant companies will not be able to delay disclosure of inside information
    • the offences would apply to both firms and individuals

    UK authorities helping markets by fostering innovation

    It is always interesting to see where the FCA intends to increase its focus of attention in the short-term. Investing £11.3m in the SRF to repeal assimilated law and replace these with FCA rules, including MiFIR transaction and reference data reporting was to be expected. 

    Tailored market abuse regimes for crypto assets and for the trading of shares in private companies shows how the UK Treasury and the FCA are both helping to foster innovation and are embracing the FCA’s secondary objective for international competitiveness and growth.   

     

    • Please get in touch to see how we can help your firm improve its monitoring controls and achieve peace of mind with regards to detecting any suspicious activity or market abuse.
  • Market Watch 77: FCA calls out organised crime groups as a risk to market integrity

    Market Watch 77: FCA calls out organised crime groups as a risk to market integrity

    It has long been known that insider dealing is typically performed by different types of market participants, from individual opportunists through to organised criminal groups (OCGs).  In the FCA’s Market Watch 77 there is a heavy focus on the risks to market integrity and firms posed by the latter. 

    Helpfully, the UK regulator outlines the characteristics and signs for firms to look out for to prevent and detect such criminal activity, including:

    • the appeal to OCGs of using equity spread bets and CFDs to optimise profits
    • trading ahead of legitimate merger and acquisition (M&A) announcements and speculation about M&A
    • the use of umbrella accounts to help mask the identity of the beneficial owners
    • feeding true and false stories about M&A to the market (the latter being a form of market manipulation)
    • the view that this activity can represent the tentacles of and a link to serious crime

    The FCA adds that suspicions should be aroused if specific clients are frequently the subject of Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs) or if several clients trade in the same security for the first time at favourable times.

    To help guard against OCGs the FCA provides a number of suggestions, including:

    • communicating to all clients that they have a zero-tolerance approach to market abuse
    • submitting STORs where appropriate, even if no public confirmation of the M&A activity is made
    • Training staff who work in M&A advisory of the risks posed by OCGs and avoid referencing the names of staff engaged in M&A advisory on the firm’s own website

    Market Watch 77 highlights the significant risks posed by OCGs to investment firms and market integrity more broadly. Where investment firms do not have effective controls in place, the FCA reminds firms that they have the option to use their enforcement powers, including requesting a FSMA s.166 report through to the variation of permissions.  

    This Market Watch re-iterates the importance of monitoring trading, communications and news together. The Kaizen surveillance platform comprises both trade and communications surveillance functionalities and is integrated with news stories from thousands of sources, sub-categorised into hundreds of market-impactful areas such as M&A, to optimise a firm’s monitoring effectiveness.

    In addition, our rules engine allows for blended alerts to be set up, for example, when high profit trades are made around significant news events (whether fake or real), making it much easier to focus on this kind of OCG activity that the FCA is keen to clamp down on.

     

    • Please get in touch to see how we can help your firm improve its monitoring controls and achieve peace of mind with regards to detecting any suspicious activity relating to OCGs.
  • US regulators continue to focus on incomplete data being submitted to surveillance platforms

    US regulators continue to focus on incomplete data being submitted to surveillance platforms

    In October last year we communicated that US regulators had imposed substantial fines on several large financial institutions for unauthorised communications on WhatsApp, iMessage and Signal and for poor record keeping and supervisory failures. 

    We also set out our thoughts regarding market abuse risk assessments and the need to have controls in place to identify situations where staff by-pass authorised communication channels while discussing work related matters and business with external parties.

    Multiple enforcement actions

    The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently announced that it has charged and fined 16 more investment firms (broker-dealers and investment advisers) for breaching recordkeeping requirements when their employees used “off-channel” communications to discuss company business.

    Employees used personal text messages to make investment recommendations and provide advice. These messages were not recorded, maintained, or preserved in violation of the federal securities laws. These breaches meant that the SEC did not have access to these off-channel communications when conducting their investigations.

    Investigations and controls undermined

    Given that unauthorised communications can significantly undermine regulatory investigations into potential insider dealing and market manipulation, as well as the effectiveness of a firm’s internal market abuse controls, we expect this to remain an area of focus for regulators globally.  Between 2020 and 2022 alone, US regulators imposed fines of $2.7 billion on financial firms for a range of different market abuse behaviours across all asset classes (Source: Deloitte Market Abuse Outlook 2022).

    Financial and reputational damage

    The majority of firms already have trade surveillance platforms in place, but these latest fines, which amounted to more than $81 million, highlight the critical need for firms to implement robust and comprehensive controls and solutions to monitor electronic communications as well. Although the fines have a financial effect on firms, there is the reputational damage that also needs to be considered. For example, the SEC publicly censured the firms and ordered them to “cease and desist” from future violations of the relevant recordkeeping provisions.

    In addition, a fine of $350 million was also recently imposed in the US on an investment bank, as a sub-set of trading and order data had not been feeding into their surveillance platforms. This further highlights the importance of checking the completeness of trading, order and communication feeds from a surveillance perspective. 

    Trade and Communication surveillance controls

    As firms navigate the evolving regulatory landscape and ongoing enforcement actions, the need to adopt and embrace new processes, controls, and technologies for a proactive approach to trade and communication surveillance is now more evident than ever.

    At Kaizen we work with our clients to ensure an understanding of both the regulatory obligations and the business benefits of monitoring trading activity as well as on and off-channel communications. By working with firms across the buy-side and sell-side, we are able to ensure our clients adopt best practices and benefit from the latest technological innovations. 

    • As regulators focus more on this area, please reach out to learn more about the ways we can assist you.
  • FCA Market Watch 76 outlines market abuse risks concerning ‘flying’ and ‘printing’

    FCA Market Watch 76 outlines market abuse risks concerning ‘flying’ and ‘printing’

    The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has shared its recent observations concerning ‘flying’ and ‘printing’ in its recent Market Watch 76 newsletter. The FCA explains that these activities create a false impression of a financial instrument’s liquidity and / or price through communicating in a misleading way.

    Back in 2018, the FCA described these two activities in Market Watch 57, including their expectations on firms in relation to trade, order and communication surveillance. Of greater concern is that in Market Watch 57 the FCA reminded firms that (back in 2015) they had highlighted their concerns regarding firms publishing incorrect volume data in Market Watch 48, including their expectation of firms. A theme is emerging here, and the FCA clearly sees the need to repeat its observations and concerns indicating that perhaps firms are failing to take note?

    The FCA’s most recent observations include cases where firms have failed to deal with ‘flying’ and ‘printing’ behaviour in a thorough or timely manner, including:

    • Failing to recognise the risks of flying and printing
    • Failing to implement proper surveillance
    • Not submitting Suspicious Transaction or Order Reports (STORs) or market observations
    • Taking too long to investigate potential misconduct.

    The FCA recommends that firms mitigate the risks associated with flying and printing in the following ways:

    • Ensuring compliance documentation prohibits this activity
    • Including these activities in (market abuse) training content
    • Ensuring that surveillance procedures to identify these activities are robust
    • Having appropriate disciplinary procedures and ensuring that commercial interests are not drivers of outcomes.

    This Market Watch reinforces the importance of having robust surveillance solutions in place to detect fictitious communications regarding bids, offers or actual trades and to automate reporting of such activity.

    In addition, these examples continue to show that firms can only really achieve assurance around market abuse regulations by having comprehensive, expertise-driven, internal frameworks across the entire compliance process; from risk assessment & policy transparency through surveillance monitoring to training and visible consequences for non-compliance.

    Given these repeated reminders and the severe consequences for firms that get this wrong, this Market Watch newsletter is an important read for all investment firms.

    • Read the Market Watch 76 Newsletter on the FCA’s website
    • For a discussion with Simon or one of our regulatory experts about your market abuse controls, please contact us.
  • Join us in New York for TSAM 2023

    Join us in New York for TSAM 2023

    We are delighted to be taking part in TSAM (The Summit of Asset Management) New York 2023 on Tuesday 31 October at the Metropolitan Pavilion. TSAM will bring together leading firms to discuss the latest challenges facing the community as well as the evolving technology and regulatory landscape.  

    Visit our stand and speak to our experts about our Surveillance and Market Abuse solutions and award winning ReportShield™ quality assurance services.

    We hope to see you there.  Click the button below for the full agenda and to register.

    Buy-side firms can register for free!

    Register here

  • Market Watch 75: FCA reminds firms of the importance of market soundings regime

    Market Watch 75: FCA reminds firms of the importance of market soundings regime

    The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority has shared its observations relating to the market soundings regime within the UK Market Abuse Regulation (MAR) in its latest Market Watch newsletter. 

    Having robust market sounding controls in place offers protection to firms from the risk of committing market abuse, as was seen in 2012, when David Einhorn and Greenlight Capital Inc were both fined by the UK regulator.

    The FCA has observed that Market Sounding Recipients (MSRs) have traded the relevant financial instruments having had an initial communication with Disclosing Market Participants (DMPs). Although the DMPs had not specifically disclosed the identities of the financial instruments to the MSRs, the MSRs were still able to identify those details using other information available to them.

    One example involved an MSR selling a financial instrument in the secondary market, then buying the same quantity of the same financial instrument back in a subsequent placing, potentially at a discount.  It’s not clear how similar this example is to when two bond traders, Darren Morton and Christopher Parry were publicly censured for market abuse by the UK regulator in 2009.

    The FCA is concerned that in some instances MSRs could have an unfair advantage over other market participants even before they have agreed to receive inside information.  To help minimise this and other associated risks, the FCA helpfully sets out several ideas and sound processes that would constitute best practice, including the suggestion that DMPs assess the scripts they use at all stages of the sounding.

    Given the serious consequences for firms and market participants that get this wrong, this Market Watch newsletter is an essential read for both sell-side and buy-side firms.

    Kaizen’s integrated surveillance solution allows firms to identify both legitimate market soundings and potential abuses of this process, and then track the trading activity of those receiving the information.

     

    • Click here to learn about our integrated surveillance solution and request a demo.
    • Or, for a discussion with Simon or one of our regulatory experts about your market abuse controls, please contact us.
  • Global regulators to continue market abuse clampdown

    Global regulators to continue market abuse clampdown

    More market abuse fines could emerge as global regulators turn their attention to control failings

    Given the importance of maintaining confidence in authorised firms and the world’s financial markets we can expect regulators around the globe to continue to clamp down on participants who commit or facilitate market abuse.

    Control failings will be punished

    In August, the SEC and CFTC imposed substantial fines in the US on several large financial institutions for unauthorised communications on WhatsApp, iMessage and Signal and for poor record keeping and supervisory failures.

    Given that these issues are not confined to the US, further enforcement action can be expected in other major financial centres given how the use of unauthorised communication channels can undermine and jeopardise an otherwise robust market abuse control framework.

    The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority has previously fined firms for having deficient surveillance processes, including communications surveillance.

    Changing landscapes and challenges

    The pandemic which led to more staff working remotely, coupled with the proliferation of new communication channels have both served to increase the challenges faced by firms when developing their market abuse control frameworks. To emphasise this point, US prosecutors recently charged an individual for allegedly disclosing inside information using Xbox audio chat.

    With the patchwork of communication channels now available and ever changing technology, firms are considering whether they should be more selective to make it easier to govern. Although these challenges mean that integrated communications surveillance is more important than ever, there are more solutions available to investment firms.

    In the main, given the challenges with data storage and importance of scalability, the shift is towards using surveillance offerings developed by specialist third parties that offer offsite, cloud solutions.

    In relation to market manipulation, layering and spoofing continues to be one of the most common types of abuse being committed. For example, on 22 August two commodity traders were given prison sentences after jury trial convictions in the US for spoofing futures on precious metals.

    Market abuse risk assessments and controls

    Given the need to monitor pre-trade activity, resultant transactions and all relevant communication channels for potential market abuse, there is a need for an automated solution in all but the smallest of firms.

    Although data collection and technology play a leading role when developing a robust market abuse control framework, there are other important factors to consider. General market abuse training for all staff as well as deeper, tailored training for different teams including surveillance analysts is crucial.

    Having a comprehensive understanding of the business conducted, IT systems, applicable regulations and associated market abuse risks is essential. Just as important is the need to capture the firm’s existing market abuse controls that help mitigate these risks. Concentrating on the residual risks associated with insider dealing and market manipulation then becomes the focus when reinforcing the robustness of your control framework.

    The changing landscape and these latest cases emphasise the need for effective controls and the importance of having a holistic and integrated approach to surveillance, including all communications channels.

    • Click here to learn about our integrated surveillance solution and request a demo.
    • Or, for a discussion with Simon or one of our regulatory experts about your market abuse controls, please contact us.
  • ESMA report shows market manipulation related STORs outnumber insider dealing

    ESMA report shows market manipulation related STORs outnumber insider dealing

    ESMA recently published a report relating to suspicious transaction and order reports (STORs) and reiterated their importance as a source of market abuse investigations. 

    The report makes it evident that Brexit has had a significant impact on the STOR-related statistics. Because of this, ESMA decided to primarily focus the main part of their analysis on STORs received during 2021 and 2022.

    ESMA found that there were no major changes to the statistics over this two-year period, as the breakdown by all measures remained relatively consistent between 2021 and 2022, including:

    • the total number of STORs received totalled 6,125 in 2021 and 5,833 in 2022. Germany submitted the most raising 42% of the total STORs in 2021 and 40% in 2022, followed by France
    • the ratio of notifications by trading venues and investment firms
    • the percentage of STORs by instrument type (87% equities and bonds 7% in both years, with derivatives and other instruments covering the remainder)
    • the type of violation – alleged market manipulation accounted for 52% of the total in both years. Whereas insider dealing-related STORs accounted for 45% of the total in 2021 and 44% in 2022.

    Market manipulation

    One of the interesting aspects of the report is that more STORs now consistently relate to market manipulation than insider dealing. Previously (between 2010 and 2018) most STORs raised related to insider dealing. 

    The increase in STORs relating to market manipulation could be a sign that firms are becoming more sophisticated in their approach to detecting potential market abuse, but it’s probably too early to say. The continued increase in electronic and algorithmic trading could also be a factor.

  • FCA highlights lack of formal market abuse controls among some CFD providers

    FCA highlights lack of formal market abuse controls among some CFD providers

    What has the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said?

    In Market Watch 73, the FCA sets out its observations from its recent market abuse peer review into Contracts for Difference (CFD) providers. While the report was largely positive it did highlight some areas of weakness. In this blog we summarise some of its key findings and why the findings matter.

    The FCA observes that the surveillance of insider dealing is soundly covered compared to market manipulation, albeit further improvements could be made. The main concerns relate to firms not considering unrealised profits when determining whether insider dealing has potentially taken place.

    In comparison, it finds that the monitoring for market manipulation is weaker. Cross product manipulation was flagged as possibly on the increase, for example manipulating the underlying asset to profit from a related CFD or spread bet.

    ‘Narrowing the spread’ – a key area of weakness

    Although most firms were aware of ‘narrowing the spread’ behaviour, with some submitting suspicious transaction and order reports (STORs), no firms had listed this type of abuse in their risk assessments or had any ‘compliance-based’ surveillance to detect it. This behaviour is harder to detect when manipulation is conducted across multiple providers or via a dealing ring.  

    Two things can help here: communications surveillance tools can help identify different parties acting in concert and across markets. Secondly, the FCA can access MiFIR transaction reporting data to help detect such behaviour across firms. They also receive order level data covering the main UK equity markets.

    Lack of surveillance for non-equity asset classes

    Market Watch 73 also reports that most firms do not have effective surveillance for non-equity asset classes. Although a common and recurring theme over the years, firms still need to consider if insider dealing or market manipulation has occurred in retail derivatives referencing any asset class, not just equities.

    A tailored Market Abuse Risk Assessment (MARA) is key to helping identify market manipulation

    Some organisations lack a formal market abuse controls framework. Firms that undertake a Market Abuse Risk Assessment (MARA) can demonstrate that they are considering relevant market abuse risks. Furthermore, a tailored MARA is much more effective at identifying such risks.

    When conducting a MARA and building a surveillance framework, it’s important to consider:

    • All asset classes
    • Cross product and cross market manipulation
    • Trading activity in its historical context
    • Unrealised as well as realised profits
    • The different ways transactions are executed
    • How pre-trade activity (Orders, RFQs, IOIs) can manipulate prices and mislead market participants
    • The level of liquidity and pre and post trade transparency at instrument and market level
    • How electronic and voice communications are monitored
    • Keeping your MARA up to date!

     

    • Read the full Market Watch 73 on the FCA’s website
    • To learn more about Kaizen’s trade and communications surveillance solutions through our acquisition of Red Deer, please contact us.
  • Kaizen Reporting acquires Red Deer

    Kaizen Reporting acquires Red Deer

    London, 19 April 2023 – Leading regulatory technology firm, Kaizen Reporting today announced that it has acquired Red Deer, a provider of integrated compliance solutions for surveillance and research workflows.

    Red Deer’s proprietary technology platform provides surveillance and research tools that help middle office and compliance teams at banks, asset management and trading firms comply with regulations, including market abuse and manipulation. Its trade and communications surveillance technology helps companies spot market abuse including spoofing, layering and other forms of manipulation in exchange and OTC markets, while the communications surveillance product can scan and trace emails and chat conversations for signs of prohibited activity. In addition, Red Deer’s online research management tools provide solutions for managing MiFID II’s Unbundling and Fair Value rules.

    The Red Deer surveillance and research tools will be available via the Kaizen Hub, a web based RegTech platform for accessing a range of compliance tools.

    Dario Crispini, CEO of Kaizen Reporting, commented:

    “As a leading RegTech provider, we are always looking to diversify our compliance offering for clients. The acquisition of Red Deer demonstrates our strengths in supporting clients with their regulatory and compliance needs and we’re delighted to offer this new range of surveillance and research tools to our clients through the Kaizen Hub.”  

    Alistair Downes, Head of Product at Red Deer, commented:

    “We are delighted to be part of Kaizen and by combining the two companies’ expertise and technology we are able to better solve clients’ regulatory challenges. Kaizen’s reputation for delivering leading services in the reporting industry along with the service and tools we offer will create an integrated solution for all of a firm’s regulatory and compliance needs.”   

    Last month Kaizen announced it had acquired a majority stake in London Reporting House, a new service that brings unrivalled insight into the repo market.

    The terms of the acquisition were not disclosed.

    (ends) 

    About Red Deer:

    Red Deer’s proprietary technology platform provides surveillance and research tools that help middle office and compliance teams at banks, private equity, asset and wealth managers and trading firms comply with regulations, including market abuse and manipulation as well as MiFID II’s unbundling and fair value rules. We have a proven track record of delivering innovative front office solutions, regulatory compliance, research consumption and cutting-edge technology to the buy side. Our technology is trusted by tier one firms within Private Equity, Alternatives, Asset Management and Wealth.

    • For more information, please contact James Dunseath, Communications Advisor, on +44 (0) 7557 955795 or media@kaizenreporting.com

     

  • FCA continues its focus on data quality and market abuse

    The FCA recently published its Annual Report and Accounts for 2019/20 wherein they discuss their sector priorities.

    Market abuse takes centre-stage but they highlighted their aim of improving the quality of firms’ transaction reports. As we know, these are the main tools used by the regulator to surveil the market but also for the investigative process where the reports act as the first port of call when analysing suspicious activity highlighted by Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs). 

    The FCA notes that they are using technology to review for both suspicious activity and for data quality. Indeed, we know that data quality is a necessary condition for an effective surveillance capability. The good news is that they noted a significant improvement in data quality. 

    Where is EMIR?

    What was surprising to me, was that EMIR reporting was not raised as a key priority.  We are currently facing unprecedented uncertainty and market volatility.  Now is the time where we need an early warning system to head off any financial sector tsunami the most. And yet, EMIR reporting was not mentioned. After more than six years and two upgrades, EMIR reporting is still not fit for purpose. Indeed, ESMA recently singled out the UK for its failure to enforce compliance with EMIR amongst the regulated community. We at Kaizen know from our extensive quality assurance testing across the sector that EMIR reporting is in a worse state than MiFID. 

     

    Annual Market Cleanliness Statistics and number of events per year

    Potentially Anomalous Trading Ratio

    During 2019/20, the FCA received 5,336 STORS and a further 788 external notifications. These resulted in 415 preliminary reviews and 53 enforcement investigations being opened. FCA activity and the level of market abuse is not necessarily the same thing, so to add to the existing estimates of market cleanliness, they have added a new measure –  the Potentially Anomalous Trading Ratio (PATR). This looks at suspicious activity rather than just correlating price movements ahead of takeover announcements. PATR is primarily based on the activity of the trading participant and whether this is outside of their normal activities. 

    The diagram below shows a price sensitive announcement (represented by the red line) and illustrates the time periods considered when constructing the PATR.

    Price sensitive announcement - FCA

     

    What stands out is the short benchmark period to assess “normal trading behaviour” of 30 days. With all the data at their fingertips, a more sophisticated measure of normal would be warranted, as a too short a measure will overstate the level of potentially abusive behaviour.  The post-announcement period is also questionable. Any parties not taking their profits in the five-day window are excluded thereby reducing the activity that falls within scope of the period resulting in an understated measure. Added to this, the records in scope exclude where individuals make a profit of less than £5000 on their trade and £50,000 for legal entities. 

    As with all measures, it has its shortcomings but it is helpful when considered with the other indicators. 

     

    Potentially Anomalous Trading Ratio results - FCA

    More to do

    Based on the measures, the FCA states that 99.2% of activity did not occur during a sensitive time period before the announcement of price sensitive information. However, 6.7% of the trading around price sensitive announces was anomalous. This may not seem like a large proportion but, when you consider the statistic is looking only at the 0.8% and is calculated in a period when there has been little takeover activity compared to prior years.  Indeed, if this is accepted as a basis for consideration of impact, it can be argued that it weakens the cost-benefit case for market-wide obligations to apply anti-market abuse measures. Insider traders are still taking a reasonable slice of the pie, so there is more to do to ensure fair markets. 

    2019 Summary - Trading Activity FCA

    • To discuss the contents of this report with Dario or one of our regulatory specialists please contact us.
    • To read the report in full visit the FCA’s website.
    • All graphics and diagrams © Financial Conduct Authority. 
  • MiFIR versus EMIR – which is the most important reporting regime?

    MiFIR versus EMIR – which is the most important reporting regime?

    There are many similarities between the MiFIR transaction reporting and EMIR trade reporting requirements. Both are T+1 reporting regimes and there is a large overlap in the instrument set that they cover. However, there are distinct regulatory drivers behind each regime: MiFIR transaction reporting is primarily used to detect market abuse whilst EMIR trade reporting is used primarily to monitor for systemic risk.

    There is no doubt that combating market abuse is a very important regulatory service; everybody benefits from clean markets. Complete and accurate transaction reports are vital to help the regulators perform this task effectively. However, systemic risk is even more important as it represents the risk of collapse of the entire financial system -there is no point monitoring for market abuse if the financial system has collapsed around you.

    It is very interesting therefore to compare the number of errors and omissions forms for MiFIR breaches against the number of equivalent forms for EMIR trade reporting breaches. Statistics from the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request show that it received notifications from 384 firms MiFIR transaction reporting breaches since go-live compared to a paltry 75 for EMIR trade reporting in the period since Q2 2018 when the EMIR breach form became available. So, it is tempting to believe that firms recognise the relative importance of EMIR trade reporting and are making greater efforts to ensure the accuracy of data they report. Sadly, this is not the case. At Kaizen, we perform data quality checks on firms’ transaction reports and trade reports. For EMIR we initially find that a much lower number of EMIR trade reports are accurate than compared with the MiFIR reports we test. This reflects the complexity of the reporting regime, but we find firms’ reporting quality rapidly improves once we have highlighted and explained the errors to them.

    So this presents an apparent anomaly. The evidence suggests the quality of EMIR trade reports is at a lower level than the quality of MiFIR transaction reports, yet over five times as many firms have notified the FCA of MiFIR transaction reporting errors than they have for EMIR trade reporting. It is not difficult to understand why this is the case; the FCA is constantly reminding the industry on the need to notify them of MiFIR transaction reporting breaches, and to correct those errors, but it appears to be comparatively silent on the need to notify them of EMIR reporting breaches. What is more difficult to understand is why the FCA appears to be less active in meeting its G20 commitments in ensuring the same level of high quality in EMIR trade reporting data.

    If you’re concerned about the quality of your MiFIR transaction reporting data or EMIR trade reporting data or would simply like confirmation that it is accurate and complete, please get in touch for a complementary consultation with one of our regulatory experts.